Tags
anti-heroine, books, Candace Bushnell, Christopher Hampton, Downton Abbey, Edith Wharton, film adaptations, Janey Wilcox, Julian Fellowes, literature, Madonna, Paul Newman, Robert DeNiro, Sally Field, The Custom of the Country, The Custom of the Country 100th anniversary, Trading Up, Uma Thurman, Undine Spragg
Part Seven in a series celebrating the 100th Anniversary of Edith Wharton’s novel The Custom of the Country.
Just as there’s a direct line from Wharton’s Undine Spragg to Madonna’s “Material Girl,” there’s a direct line from Undine to the heroine of Candace Bushnell’s 2003 novel Trading Up, Janey Wilcox. Janey is beautiful, ambitious, and determined to get money and status in New York through trading one man for another. Her husband Selden (shades of Lawrence Selden in The House of Mirth), thinks at one point that “Ever since they had returned from their honeymoon, she’d been attacking New York with the zeal of a mountain climber determined to reach the highest summit, with him, it seemed, relegated to a Sherpa in cummerbund and black tie.”
Bushnell acknowledges the link to Wharton when Janey tells Selden The Custom of the Country should be a movie. She’s been trying to persuade her former lover Comstock Dibble, head of Parador Pictures, that he’s the right man to make it: “‘It’s never been done before and he’d be good at it.’” I agree with her that it would make a great movie. I would love to see Undine as a film star—it just might be “the one part she was really made for” (of course I’m quoting her thoughts from the novel out of context here, but the line fits my own purpose so well!).
At one point there were plans for a film adaptation, written and directed by Christopher Hampton, but the film never materialized. In 1995, Entertainment Weekly advertized the adaptation: “Midwestern beauty Undine Spragg (Uma Thurman) and her parents (Sally Field, Paul Newman) move to turn-of-the-century New York City to take society by storm. But will a youthful indiscretion—namely her ex-husband (Robert De Niro)—spoil Undine’s plans?”
While there is as yet no film version of The Custom of the Country, Wharton’s “Big Novel” has influenced Julian Fellowes and the creation of Downton Abbey, as well as Candace Bushnell and her New York heroines. Fellowes says that after discovering The House of Mirth, “I moved on from Lily Bart to The Custom of the Country and it is quite true that I felt this was my book; that the novel was talking to me in a most extreme and immediate way. I think it’s a remarkable piece of writing. In Undine Spragg, Wharton has created an anti-heroine absolutely in the same rank as Becky Sharp, Scarlet O’Hara, or Lizzy Eustace. Undine has no values except ambition, greed and desire, and yet through the miracle of Wharton’s writing, you are on her side. That’s what’s so extraordinary about the book…. All of this was a tremendous inspiration to me. I decided, largely because of her work, that it was time I wrote something. Because of Edith Wharton and the old saying ‘write what you know,’ I decided to write what I knew, not to try and find a more interesting story than my own but to write about my own past and the world I’d grown up in.”
What do you think of the connections between Wharton’s novels and Downton Abbey? Do you see Undine’s influence on the series, and on Bushnell’s heroines (and anti-heroines)?
Next in this series: Part Eight: What Edith Wharton Tells Us About The Way We Live Now—The Custom of the Country and Edith Wharton in Context, edited by Laura Rattray
My other posts on The Custom of the Country:
Part One: How I Discovered The Custom of the Country
Part Two: “The greatest knack for finding names”
Part Three: “I’ll never try anything again till I try New York”
Part Four: Undine Spragg as the Empress Josephine
Part Five: Marriage, Divorce, and “diversified elements of misery”
Part Six: “Diamonds are a Girl’s Best Friend”
That moment when you’re revising obsessively and it feels like “an attack of scrupulosis”…: On revising The Custom of the Country
Happy 100th Anniversary to Edith Wharton’s The Custom of the Country! The first installment of the novel was published in Scribner’s Magazine in January 1913.
Writing with “dogged obstinacy”: In the summer of 1911, Edith Wharton was “digging away” at her “Big Novel,” The Custom of the Country, wondering if “dogged obstinacy” could “replace freedom & inspiration.”
“The books were too valuable to be taken down”: On Undine Spragg’s treatment of her son Paul in the last chapter of The Custom of the Country, and Paul’s experience of nightmarish library in which the books can never be read, and no one ever writes.
French Fact and American Fiction: Wharton’s use of place names in The Custom of the Country.
Pingback: “Diamonds are a Girl’s Best Friend” | Sarah Emsley
Spoiler alert:
Connections: Alas, Edith Wharton and Julian Fellowes dispatch characters in the most “unkind” and cruel manner! (Disclaimer: I’m a card carrying member of Team Sybil!!!) When I saw he was visiting the Mount in Nov 2012, I wanted to drive out there and heckle him for awful, vile, disgusting, nasty way he handled Lady Sybil’s leaving. Medical error, seriously????? My snarky comment was
“What, he’s out there to learn more about writing unhappy endings?” Little did I know what he was going to do to Matthew. On Christmas Day!! (I’m connected with UK fan pages/roleplayers).
“On Undine’s side”??? No, Lord J, no! Lord J and Edith Wharton certainly write so well on “upstairs” persons. However, “downstairs” Thomas Barrow seems to be the “Undine” of Downton. I’m not on Thomas’ side, lol.
LikeLike
Yes, poor Sybil – and poor Matthew! I watched all of Downton Abbey except for that last episode, because I already knew what was going to happen (it’s so hard to avoid spoilers on Twitter). Just can’t bring myself to watch it, and thus I don’t know yet if I’ll watch the new season, either. But it’s true that if you want to learn more about how to write an unhappy ending, Edith Wharton is a good teacher.
I hadn’t thought of Thomas as the Undine of Downton – excellent comparison. Now that you mention it, it seems obvious. Still looking for his Elmer Moffatt….
LikeLike
Thanks! I wish Thomas would find his Elmer Moffatt and move out of the Abbey! There were quite a few people locally who said they were done with Downton Abbey after season three. The ratings in the UK don’t reflect that yet. I was certain they would drop here(US) too. That will be interesting. The first two episodes of season four have not been especially interesting, in my view. Certainly had some good moments and three(more actually) very dull plot lines indeed(just finished a rereading of Emma).
LikeLike
Downton very dull?! How disappointing. There were things I didn’t like about the last season, but at least it wasn’t dull.
LikeLike
I agree! There is something quite uncanny in Bushnell’s Sex in the City too. Not the TV version but the actual novel – I think it was a novel – it has been a long time since I read it. And the the TV version came out much softer and gentler – almost an Austen make over! Now if you think this is an outrageous suggestion I’ll understand – even I’m thinking is is a bit far fetched. But mercenary marriages and connections are not far away!
LikeLike
Yes! I think there’s some Austen as well as some Wharton behind Sex and the City. Lady Susan and Mary Crawford especially, but also the ongoing focus on marriage and money.
LikeLike
Pingback: What Edith Wharton Tells Us About The Way We Live Now | Sarah Emsley
Pingback: How Much Did Edith Wharton Revise The Custom of the Country? | Sarah Emsley
Pingback: Edith Wharton’s Portrait of a Lady | Sarah Emsley
Pingback: The Custom of the Country Turns 101 Today | Sarah Emsley